A comparison of the similarities and differences between the characters winston smith and guy montag

In short, both societies are desensitised, with governments that control the people through the control of the flow of information and a system whereby deviants are simply marked down and eliminated.

Both main characters, at the start, lead meaningless, bland lives; one day, a girl or woman appears, changing them forever; they rebel completely against their society, but eventually they calm down.

One of the most glaring similarities, perhaps, is the character development arc. On the contrary, in the nuclear war has stopped any further use of atomic weapons and in fact has ensured the dictatorships will remain stable forever. However, the character of Guy Montag Fahrenheit ultimately triumphs — he evades the government, finds peace in a community of like-minded people, and escapes destruction in the nuclear war.

1984 versus Fahrenheit 451 – a comparison

However, the figures IN power are fundamentally different. Smith and Montag therefore have quite a few similarities in the way that neither of them are depicted as "traditional" heroes.

Montag for example, although he may look the part and his role may be suitable, being a member of the fire department whose job it is to police the censuring of books, morally seems to be rather ambiguous in terms of where his real loyalties lie.

1984 Essay | Essay

Both of these characters seem rather interesting choices to be heroes battling against the oppressive restrictions of a dystopian society. Although there is a touch of irony in this quote, it clearly presents Smith as a man who is not physically in peak condition.

It prefers to use television to numb the minds of the population and it will gladly burn the opposition to reach this goal, be they books or humans. Furthermore, the government in relies largely on brainwashing and totalitarian policies that involve mass surveillance and spies, with organisations, namely the Spies and the Youth League, similar to the Hitler Youth: While the theme of a government which alters history is present in both of said books, the alteration is much more in the foreground of than it is in Fahrenheitand it is used extensively to indicate the nature of the regime itself.

At times in the novel he comes across as almost a pathetic figure, as in the following quote, when he is doing his physical exercise, encouraged by the female through the telescreen: In short, the Party cares for the thought, not the act.

Therefore, one can safely say they are very different novels while at the same time putting them in the same category. Although eventually he does end up successfully opposing the government of this dystopian regime and all they stand for, the reader gets the idea that this is a close-cut theme.

In conclusion, I will re-state my earlier point that the two books have many fine, inconspicuous differences that nonetheless very much separate them under close examination.

This is shown in the way Orwell transitions from a war with Eurasia, changing suddenly to a war with Eastasia halfway through, to an ending of: Apart from anything else, can also be considered a sort of satirical romance, whereas Fahrenheit has no real element of romance whatsoever.

He, in some ways, represents a character that Faber and Beatty have to fight for, to persuade and to win him to their cause. At times, the novel presents him as being rather Montag is not your traditional hero therefore.

In the same way, Winston Smith can definitely does not fit the bill of being a hero who opposes his own dystopian society. Both are works of dystopian fiction, though of a somewhat different nature.

Winston Smith, on the other hand, fails and eventually submits to brainwashing. The idea behind this is a possible reference to the theory of mutually-assured destruction, or MAD for short.

Fahrenheit was published in by Ray Bradbury. At times, the novel presents him as being rather indecisive, and he is battled over by both Beatty and Faber, representing respectively the banning of books and the freedom of books. In this essay, I hope to illustrate the differences and similarities between the two novels.

Consider too the way in which he has no idea of how he can rebel and what he can do to oppose Big Brother. Physically, he is presented as a middle-aged man with certain physical weaknesses who has a desire to rebel and to be part of the Brotherhood but whose every attempt to rebel is watched and noted by the Party., Gattaca, Fahrenheit Winston Smith - A member of the Party in near-future London, Winston Smith is a frail, contemplative, and intellectual thirty-nine-year-old.

Guy Montag burns books in a future America. In Montag’s world, firemen start fires rather than putting them out. Main characters Created By: Donavan Morrell Tara. Fahrenheit Plot Summary Oceania America Similarities in Setting Similarities in Tone Similarities in Mood Guy Montag and Winston Smith Clarisse McClellan and Julia Mildred Montag and Winstons Wife and the surrounding symbols that interact with these character.

NOV versus Fahrenheit – a comparison was. vs. Fahrenheit Essay. Words Apr 2nd, 11 Pages. Fahrenheit tells of Guy Montag’s experience in a society where books have become illegal and the population has become addicted to television.

Meanwhile, deals with Winston Smith’s affairs in Oceania, a state controlled by the totalitarian regime known as the.

Winston Smith vs.

Compare and contrast Winston Smith from 1984 and Guy Montag from Fahrenheit 45

Guy Montag Characters, Theories and Principles of George Orwell's Novel Essay - Comparison Of By George Orwell To The Actual Since the onset of the United States, Americans have always viewed the future in two ways; one, as the perfect society with a perfect government, or two, as a.

There are many similarities between the society in and the society in Fahrenheitas well as many differences. The most obvious characteristics of a dystopian society are the restriction of information and history, independent thought, and freedom (Wright). In Winston Smith goes against the party in order to live freely, doing.

Character Comparisons of Winston vs. Guy in Fahrenheit and Words 4 Pages Winston Smith vs. Guy Montag The two protagonists in Fahrenheit and both started out somewhere, following the rules and doing what they were told, and towards the end of the book you see them change and become completely different .

A comparison of the similarities and differences between the characters winston smith and guy montag
Rated 0/5 based on 39 review